Which Finger Lake Is Best for Fishing?

The Finger Lakes region of New York State is a popular spot for fishing enthusiasts. The area is home to 11 long and narrow bodies of water that are perfect for fishing.

From trout and bass to salmon and pike, the Finger Lakes provide a wide range of species and excellent fishing opportunities. So which Finger Lake is best for fishing?

One of the most popular lakes in the region is Seneca Lake. It is the deepest of the Finger Lakes and has some of the best bass fishing in the area.

The lake also offers walleye, northern pike, muskellunge, bullhead catfish, channel catfish, yellow perch, and brown trout. The lake has several access points as well as boat launches.

Cayuga Lake is another great spot for anglers. It offers excellent smallmouth bass fishing as well as walleye and northern pike.

There are also plenty of other fish such as panfish, catfish, brown trout, rainbow trout, carp, and brown bullhead. Cayuga Lake has many access points along its shoreline as well as boat launches.

Keuka Lake is a great choice for anglers seeking a variety of fish species. It offers an abundance of cold-water fish such as lake trout, landlocked salmon, rainbow trout and brown trout.

Keuka also has warm-water species like smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, walleye and northern pike. There are several access points along Keuka’s shoreline.


The Finger Lakes region offers some of the best fishing in New York State. Each lake has its own unique characteristics that make it ideal for different types of anglers.

Seneca Lake is known for its excellent bass fishing while Cayuga Lake provides excellent smallmouth bass fishing opportunities. Keuka Lake offers an abundance of cold-water fish species such as lake trout and landlocked salmon.

No matter which Finger Lake you choose to visit you will be sure to find great opportunities for a successful day on the water.

Photo of author

Michael Allen