Which Finger Lake Has the Best Fishing?

The Finger Lakes region of New York State is a great destination for those looking to enjoy some of the best fishing around. With nearly 11,000 acres of water to choose from, anglers can find plenty of opportunities to land their favorite fish.

The most popular Finger Lake for fishing is undoubtedly Seneca Lake. This lake is home to an abundance of both warm and cold-water species, including largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, walleyes, muskellunge and northern pike. The lake also offers excellent trolling opportunities for anglers looking to Target trout and salmon.

Cayuga Lake is another great spot for fishing in the Finger Lakes region.

This lake boasts a wide variety of fish species, including several different types of panfish, as well as largemouth bass and smallmouth bass. Anglers can also find plenty of opportunities to catch walleye here too.

Canandaigua Lake is another popular destination for fishermen in the Finger Lakes region. This lake has a variety of gamefish species, such as largemouth bass, smallmouth bass and walleye. Additionally, there are plenty of excellent trolling opportunities available here too.

Keuka Lake is yet another great option for anglers looking to enjoy some top-notch fishing in the Finger Lakes region. This lake offers some fantastic fishing for both warm and cold-water species like trout and salmon, as well as plenty of other gamefish such as northern pike and muskellunge.

Which Finger Lake Has the Best Fishing?

There’s no definitive answer here – it really comes down to personal preference! Each Finger Lake offers its own unique fishing experience with plenty of different options available depending on what type of fish you’re looking to Target.


All four Finger Lakes – Seneca, Cayuga, Canandaigua and Keuka – are excellent destinations for anglers looking to experience some top-notch fishing in New York State. All offer an abundance of gamefish species with plenty of trolling opportunities available depending on your preference.

Photo of author

Emma Gibson