Is Spearfishing Unethical?

Spearfishing is a form of fishing that uses a spear, or a similar implement, to capture fish. It is an ancient practice that dates back thousands of years and is still popular today. Spearfishing allows fishers to Target specific species of fish, which can result in fewer bycatch and less impacts on the environment. However, some people consider it to be unethical due to the potential for overfishing and the potential cruelty inflicted on the animals.

One of the primary criticisms of spearfishing is that it can lead to overfishing, as fishers are able to Target specific species of fish and catch large quantities in a short amount of time. This can have serious consequences for both the Targeted species and other species in the area. Overfishing can lead to population declines in certain species, which can have ripple effects throughout an ecosystem. Furthermore, it can lead to changes in food webs and cause imbalances throughout an entire ecosystem.

In addition, some people consider spearfishing to be cruel because it involves killing animals for food or sport. This is especially true if fishers are using methods such as “fish bombing” where explosives are used to stun or kill fish. These methods are considered by some to be unnecessarily cruel and unethical.

However, proponents of spearfishing argue that it can be an ethical activity when done responsibly. Responsible spearfishers adhere to regulations regarding size limits and bag limits, as well as only Targeting non-endangered species. These measures help ensure that overfishing does not occur and that populations remain stable over time. Additionally, they argue that when done correctly, spearfishing can actually provide more humane deaths than other types of fishing since they Target specific fish instead of indiscriminately catching all types of marine life.


Ultimately, whether or not spearfishing is ethical depends on how it is practiced. When done responsibly with proper regulations and respect for the environment and marine life, then it can be considered ethical. However, if done irresponsibly with disregard for regulations or animal welfare then it should be considered unethical.

Photo of author

Michael Allen