Is Spearfishing Cruel?

Spearfishing is an ancient method of fishing that has been used by humans for thousands of years. It is a method of fishing which involves the use of a spear, or long pole with a pointed end, to catch fish. It is usually done by free-diving, that is, diving without the use of scuba gear or oxygen tanks. This means that the diver must be able to hold their breath for long periods of time underwater in order to search and hunt for fish.

The debate over whether or not spearfishing is cruel has been ongoing for many years.

Proponents of spearfishing argue that it is a humane way to catch fish as it allows the fisherman to Target specific species and sizes, rather than using nets or other methods which can be indiscriminate in terms of which species are caught. Additionally, they argue that it minimizes the amount of suffering caused to the fish since they are killed quickly and humanely with the spear.

Opponents of spearfishing point out that it can still be an inherently cruel practice as it can cause unnecessary suffering and pain to the fish being Targeted. They argue that due to lack of training and experience, many fishermen fail to hit their Targets accurately and cause more suffering than necessary. Furthermore, some oppose this method due to its impact on local ecosystems as it can disrupt delicate marine habitats if done incorrectly or excessively.


Overall, whether or not spearfishing is cruel depends on how it is practiced and who is doing it. If done correctly with proper training and experience, then it can be an efficient and humane way to catch fish without causing unnecessary suffering or damage to local ecosystems. However, if done incorrectly or excessively then it can cause unnecessary pain and suffering as well as damage delicate marine habitats.

Photo of author

Daniel Bennet