How Is the Fishing in Cayuga Lake?

Fishing in Cayuga Lake is a great way to spend a day in the Finger Lakes region of New York. With its long, deep lake, there are plenty of opportunities for anglers to catch a variety of fish.

Cayuga Lake is home to largemouth and smallmouth bass, walleye, yellow perch, and even some northern pike. Anglers can also find brown bullhead and pumpkinseed sunfish in the lake’s waters.

The best time of year to fish in Cayuga Lake is typically from April to October. During this time, the water temperature is ideal for catching a variety of game fish species.

Fishing Techniques

Anglers have a few options when it comes to fishing techniques on Cayuga Lake. Fly fishing is popular for catching trout and other species.

Trolling or drifting with bait or lures can also be effective for catching bass and walleye.

Fishing Regulations

It’s important to be aware of all regulations before heading out on the lake. New York state has specific regulations regarding size limits and season dates for different species of fish that must be followed by all anglers.

Fishing Charters

For those who don’t have their own boat or equipment, there are several fishing charters available on Cayuga Lake that will take you out on the water and provide you with everything you need for a successful fishing trip.


Fishing on Cayuga Lake can be an enjoyable experience for anglers of all levels. With its variety of fish species, ample opportunities for fly-fishing, trolling, and live bait fishing, as well as guided charters available year-round, it’s easy to find success when fishing on this beautiful Finger Lakes lake.

Photo of author

Emma Gibson